How to Choose Between Several Options You Like Equally
When you like two options equally, the problem is rarely a lack of information: it’s that you don’t have a method for comparing them. In this tutorial you’ll go from a dead-end doubt to a reasoned decision, with clear criteria for choosing between two degrees or any set of similar academic options. We start with what you need to clarify before comparing anything.
Step 1. Recognize what kind of tie you have
If you’re wondering what to do when you like several options equally, the first move is to diagnose the tie. Not all ties are the same. Sometimes two options appeal to you because they share a common base, for example an interest in understanding how people work or in solving problems with data. Other times they are very different options that meet different needs: one gives you creativity and the other stability, for example.
Telling them apart changes your approach. If they share a base, you probably have an underlying interest that you can fulfil in several ways, and the decision will be less dramatic than it seems. If they are different, you’re choosing between study and work lifestyles, and it’s worth comparing more carefully.
Write each option on a sheet of paper and note in short sentences why it appeals to you. Look at the words that repeat. If «I like researching» or «I want to help others» shows up in both, there’s a common thread. If the reasons have nothing in common, your tie is real and you’ll need explicit criteria. This diagnosis takes little time and stops you from comparing details without knowing what you’re actually looking for.
Step 2. Separate what you want from what others expect
An apparent tie can hide one option you truly like and another you like because it pleases the people around you. Before applying any criteria, check that both options are really yours. Ask yourself which one you would choose if nobody were going to have an opinion about your decision, and which one if you had to explain it to a group of people who matter to you.
If you notice that the answer changes depending on who is watching, there is probably outside pressure at play. It’s very common and it doesn’t mean you have to ignore anyone, but it’s worth seeing clearly; you can learn more about how family pressure when choosing a degree works so you can recognize its signs.
A good exercise is to write a short note to yourself with the reasons for each option and mark in one color the ones that depend on other people’s opinions. What remains unmarked is your decision base. If, after filtering, one option loses almost all its arguments, the tie was less real than you thought. If both are still standing, you move on to the next step with the peace of mind of comparing authentic options.
Step 3. Define your selection criteria
Without criteria, comparing just means going in circles. The criteria for deciding between similar options are the questions both options must answer, and they come from you, not from a universal list. Pick a few that really matter to you and write them as concrete questions.
- Do I enjoy the kind of tasks that will fill my day-to-day study?
- Am I interested in the content even in its difficult or dry parts?
- What doors does each option open and which does it close?
- How much uncertainty can I tolerate on each path?
- Does it fit the kind of life I want in the medium term?
Avoid vague criteria like «it’ll go well for me». A useful question can be answered with facts or experiences: «have I enjoyed doing something similar to this?» is better than «will it be interesting?». And keep the list short: too many criteria dilute the decision and bring you back to the tie, because almost everything ends up balancing out.
Step 4. Prioritize your criteria before scoring
Prioritizing options starts with prioritizing criteria. If you treat them all equally, a small advantage in a trivial aspect can offset a huge difference in something essential. Rank your criteria from most to least relevant to you and decide which are non-negotiable and which are merely desirable.
A simple method is to compare them in pairs: take two criteria and ask yourself which one you would sacrifice first. Repeat with every combination and see which ones win most often. You don’t need sophisticated arithmetic; it’s enough that the resulting order feels familiar, almost obvious, when you read it.
Then score each option on each criterion using a simple scale, such as low, medium or high, and look at where differences appear in the criteria that matter most. What happens in the secondary criteria only breaks the tie at the end. If both options score the same on the essentials, you haven’t wasted your time: you’ve discovered that you can choose without fear of making a serious mistake.
Step 5. Get first-hand information
Your scores are only worth as much as the information behind them. If you picture a degree from a general description, it’s easy for your idea to differ from reality. To test your assumptions, look for direct experiences with each option.
- Talk to students who are already taking each option and ask them what the everyday routine is like and what is hardest.
- Review the curricula or content programs and notice which subjects spark your curiosity and which leave you indifferent.
- Try a sample: an open course, an introductory book or a small project related to each option.
- Talk to professionals who work in that field about what their real working day looks like.
When you try things out, pay attention to how you feel during the activity, not just afterwards. If you lose track of time with one and keep checking the clock with the other, that’s valuable data. Write down your impressions and review your criteria table again: some scores will probably change once you check them against reality.
Step 6. Test the decision before making it
If you’re still doubtful after all this, use techniques that simulate the choice. The first is to live with one option for a few days as if you had already chosen it: imagine you picked the first one, think about your coming years in it and observe your emotional reaction. Then repeat with the second. What matters isn’t the reasoning that comes up, but whether you feel relief, excitement or rejection.
The second technique is to ask yourself which one you would regret not having tried more. Anticipated regret often gives you information that rational criteria don’t capture. The third is to assess reversibility: which option lets you change course at the lowest cost if you get it wrong? If one of them leaves more paths open, it has a real practical advantage when everything else is equal.
If deep down you don’t even know what drives you, the problem may be broader than a simple comparison, and it will help to go over what to study when you don’t have a clear path to rebuild your interests from scratch.
Step 7. Decide, set a date and review
A decision that never closes becomes a constant drain. Set a specific moment to decide and stick to it. Before that moment you can keep gathering information; afterwards, your task is to commit. This doesn’t mean you can’t change course, only that you avoid the paralysis of comparing indefinitely.
When you decide, write down your reasons. They will remind you why you chose when the hard days arrive, and they will arrive with any option. Also set a review point in advance: after a reasonable period of study, ask yourself whether the experience confirms your expectations. That way you turn the choice into a hypothesis you test, not an irrevocable sentence.
Also think about how you can keep the option you set aside: as an elective subject, a hobby, a personal project or complementary training. Often choosing one option doesn’t mean giving up the other entirely, and knowing that greatly reduces the anguish of deciding.
What usually goes wrong when deciding between similar options
There are pitfalls worth spotting early. One is looking for the perfect option: when two alternatives appeal to you equally, neither will be ideal in everything, and waiting for absolute certainty only prolongs the doubt. Another is letting fear of making a mistake outweigh excitement; if you choose only to avoid the worst-case scenario, you probably won’t choose what truly motivates you.
It’s also a mistake to compare an idealized version of one option with the real version of the other. If you know one better, you tend to see its flaws and imagine the other without any. Balance the level of information on both before scoring. And beware of deciding in a bad emotional moment: a day of exhaustion or euphoria distorts your criteria and leaves its mark on the decision.
Finally, avoid consulting too many people. Each opinion adds noise and, if your criteria aren’t clear, you’ll end up adopting other people’s. Listen to someone who knows the field well, or to yourself, but always filter through your own priorities.
If, after comparing your essential criteria, the two options are still tied, choose the one that lets you change course at the lowest cost and the one that excites you most when you imagine starting tomorrow.
Frequently asked questions
How long should I spend deciding between two options?
There is no universal length. What helps is setting a reasonable deadline based on your circumstances and using that time to gather real information, not to repeat the same doubts. When the date arrives, decide with what you know.
What if my criteria don’t match what my gut feelings tell me?
That discrepancy is information. Check whether your criteria truly reflect what you value or include reasons inherited from others. Sometimes intuition points to a criterion you forgot to write down; add it and compare again.
Is it a bad sign if I don’t lean toward either one?
Not necessarily. It may mean both fit your interests and either would be a valid choice. In that case, reversibility, the possibility of combining fields and how you feel imagining the first day in each one carry more weight.
Can I decide by flipping a coin?
It can work as an emotional test, not as the final decision. While the coin is in the air, notice which result you hope for. If you feel a clear preference, you already have your answer; if you don’t care, both options are probably equivalent for you.






